In Great Am. Ins. Co. v. Employers Mut. Cas. Co., both the Great American and Employers’ umbrella policies were “excess,” in that they both provided coverage for liability “in excess” of a “retained limit.” That said . . .
- the Employers’ policy defined “retained limit” as “the available limits of all ‘underlying insurance,’” a term that was, in turn, defined by two descriptions of primary coverage; while
- the Great American policy defined “retained limit” to include “the applicable limits of any other insurance providing coverage to the ‘Insured’ during the Policy Period.” (emphasis added).
Thus, “[b]ased on the plain terms of these policies, the Great American Umbrella Policy was the true excess policy after all other policies.” No. 20-11113 (Nov. 17, 2021).